Skip to main content

FDA Registration Assistance

FDA Import Alert 99-38 low-acid canned and acidified food process control
FDA Import Alerts · Canned Foods
Last updated:

FDA Import Alert 99-38: Canned Foods With Inadequate Process Control

Import Alert 99-38 lets FDA detain low-acid canned foods and acidified foods from listed processors without examining them when inspections, tests or field exams show the process may not control Clostridium botulinum. Retort and aseptic system problems, missing records, untrained supervisors and pH above 4.6 are typical findings. Removal needs process records, process authority review and heat penetration data.

Short answer: FDA Import Alert 99-38 allows detention without physical examination of low-acid canned foods and acidified foods from listed processors when inspections, sample results or field exams show the products may not have been made to control the growth and toxin production of Clostridium botulinum. The charges are inadequate acidification and inadequate process controls under section 402(a)(4). Removal requires evidence of compliance with 21 CFR Part 108 and Part 113 or 114, such as production records, process authority review and heat penetration data, emailed to Importalerts2@fda.hhs.gov.

Listed on 99-38? Send us the firm name, the FDA findings and your process filings. We plan the corrective actions and the removal evidence.

Get a 99-38 Case Review
At a Glance

Import Alert 99-38 Basics

ItemImport Alert 99-38
Official titleDWPE of LACF or Acidified Foods Due to Inadequate Process Control
ConcernGrowth and toxin production of Clostridium botulinum or other harmful microorganisms
Rules21 CFR Part 108, Part 113 (LACF) and Part 114 (acidified foods)
ChargesSection 402(a)(4), refusal under 801(a)(3); codes NEEDS ACID and INADPRCCTL
CountriesMany, with China the largest group
Removal contactImportalerts2@fda.hhs.gov

Details follow the current text of Import Alert 99-38, published October 27, 2026.

Listed Products

Products Listed Under 99-38

Canned vegetables

Beans, peas, carrots, asparagus, bamboo shoots, mushrooms and truffles.

Canned seafood

Abalone, scallops, crab, shrimp, sardines, mackerel, herring, eel and clams.

Aseptic drinks

Coconut drinks, milk beverages, tea and coffee drinks.

Herbal jelly

Grass and herbal jelly products.

Acidified foods

Acidified wet wheat noodles and pickled mustard stems.

Pouches and jars

Cans, glass jars and hermetically sealed foil-film pouches.

Common Findings

What FDA Inspections Found

FindingRegulation
Deviations from the scheduled process not identified21 CFR 113.89
Retort or sterilizer without an accurate temperature-indicating device21 CFR 113.40
Processing not done to at least the filed scheduled process21 CFR 108.35(c)(3)(i)
Production records not made when observed21 CFR 113.100(a)
Operators not supervised by a Better Process Control School graduate21 CFR 108.35(g) and 113.10
No routine pH testing to keep equilibrium pH at 4.6 or below21 CFR 114.80(a)(2)
Container coding missing establishment, product or date21 CFR 114.80(b)

We review process filings as part of LACF registration and process filing.

Release and Removal

Two Tracks: Releasing a Shipment vs Leaving the List

Release one shipment

The alert does not set out a lab-testing route for single shipments. Ask the FDA Division compliance office in the notice what it will consider, typically production and process records for the specific lots, the process authority's review and any deviation records. Otherwise the outcome is export or destruction.

Removal from the Red List

Evidence of compliance with 21 CFR Part 108 and Part 113 or 114: production records showing the scheduled process was followed, photos of equipment, process authority evaluation, heat penetration data and, where available, a third-party certification. Documents should be in English. Email Importalerts2@fda.hhs.gov under RPM Chapter 9-8.

Removal Evidence

What a Strong 99-38 Request Includes

  • Production records showing each lot was made to the filed scheduled process.
  • Photos of retorts, aseptic systems, temperature-indicating devices and recorders.
  • A recognized process authority's evaluation of the process.
  • Heat penetration data showing the thermal process works, or pH records for acidified foods.
  • Third-party certification against 21 CFR Part 108 and Part 113 or 114, and training records for supervisors.
How It Works

Our Import Alert 99-38 Process

1
Confirm the listingWe read the Red List entry and the inspection findings.
2
Root causeWe map each finding to the regulation and the fix.
3
Process authorityWe coordinate re-evaluation, heat penetration and filing updates.
4
Evidence packageWe assemble records, photos and certifications in English.
5
Request and follow-upWe send the request to Importalerts2@fda.hhs.gov and answer FDA questions.

FDA's framework is in RPM Chapter 9-8; FDA removal guidance explains what a request should include.

Related Help

Import Alert Resources

Import Alert Removal

Removal help for food and supplements.

Import Alert 99-36

No reply to FDA process requests.

Import Alert 99-37

Unregistered or unfiled canned foods.

LACF Registration

FCE registration and process filing.

Acidified Foods

Rules for importing acidified foods.

Canned Food Detained

What to do when FDA holds a canned food entry.

Start With the Listing

Get Help With Import Alert 99-38

We map each FDA finding to a corrective action, coordinate the process authority work and prepare the removal request. We are an independent compliance firm, not FDA or a law firm, and no one can guarantee FDA's decision.

  • Custom-scoped quote based on your listing and products.
  • Exporters, manufacturers and U.S. importers.
  • Agree the scope and pricing before any paid work begins.

Contact our specialists, email info@fdaregistrationassistance.com, or call +1 (928) 275-8333. Import alert removal · Food services · Contact.

Get a 99-38 Case Review

FDA Registration Assistance is a private consulting firm, not FDA or any government agency. FDA registration is not FDA approval, clearance or certification.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions — Import Alert 99-38

What is FDA Import Alert 99-38?

Import Alert 99-38 is titled "Detention Without Physical Examination of Low-Acid Canned Foods or Acidified Foods Due to Inadequate Process Control." It lets FDA detain listed products without examining each shipment.

Why does FDA put a processor on 99-38?

When inspections, analytical results, field exams or other data show products were not made to control the growth and toxin production of Clostridium botulinum or other harmful microorganisms.

What are the charges under Import Alert 99-38?

Two charges, both adulteration under section 402(a)(4) with refusal under 801(a)(3): prepared, packed or held under insanitary conditions due to inadequate acidification (NEEDS ACID), or due to inadequate process controls (INADPRCCTL).

Which regulations does 99-38 enforce?

21 CFR Part 108, the low-acid canned food rules in Part 113 and the acidified food rules in Part 114.

Does 99-38 apply to products that were never filed?

No. It applies only when the firm has filed a scheduled process. Firms that did not register or file are covered by Import Alert 99-37.

Which products are on Import Alert 99-38?

Canned vegetables, canned seafood, aseptic coconut, milk, tea and coffee drinks, herbal jelly, acidified noodles and pickled mustard stems, in cans, glass and foil-film pouches. Some entries cover all of a firm's low-acid or acidified foods.

What problems do FDA inspections find?

Common findings include unidentified process deviations, retorts or sterilizers without accurate temperature devices, processing below the filed process, records not kept when observed, operators without Better Process Control School supervision and no routine pH testing for acidified foods.

What pH applies to acidified foods?

Acidified foods must reach a finished equilibrium pH of 4.6 or below. One listing cites a processor that did not test pH routinely to ensure this.

How do I know if my firm is on Import Alert 99-38?

Open Import Alert 99-38 and search the Red List by country and firm name. Each entry shows the product and the date it was added. Check before every shipment season, since the alert is updated often.

Can a lab test get a 99-38 shipment released?

The alert does not set out a testing route, because the problem is how the product was processed. Ask the FDA Division compliance office in the notice what it will consider for that entry.

What evidence does FDA want for removal from 99-38?

Records showing products were made to the scheduled process, photos of equipment, a process authority's evaluation, heat penetration data showing the thermal process works and certification from a third party that the processor meets 21 CFR Part 108 and Part 113 or 114.

How do I get my firm removed from Import Alert 99-38?

Email the evidence to Importalerts2@fda.hhs.gov. FDA's Division of Import Operations forwards removal requests to the Human Foods Program for evaluation. See RPM Chapter 9-8.

Do removal documents need to be in English?

Yes. The alert says documents should be in English, or removal may be delayed.

Who do I contact at FDA about Import Alert 99-38?

Removal petitions go to Importalerts2@fda.hhs.gov. The alert lists the Division of Import Operations at (301) 796-0356 or Imports@fda.hhs.gov, and HFP-OCE-Imports@fda.hhs.gov for food policy questions.

Can you guarantee removal from Import Alert 99-38?

No. FDA makes every removal decision. We are an independent compliance firm, not FDA or a law firm. We help you build a complete, well-documented request.

HM
Reviewed By Hector Matos, Senior Regulatory Compliance Specialist · 15+ years FDA compliance experience · Updated October 2026
Discuss Your Project

Request an Import Alert 99-38 Case Review

Tell us what your company makes, sells, or distributes, where each product is manufactured or packed, your U.S. importer or buyer arrangement, label readiness, and target shipment date.

Submitting this inquiry does not purchase a service or authorize paid work. Our team can discuss the scope and required materials before you commission assistance. Fields marked with an asterisk are required.

Please do not include payment details, medical records, or other sensitive information. You can also email our team or call +1 (928) 275-8333.