Skip to main content

FDA Registration Assistance

FDA Import Alert 54-10 aristolochic acid in dietary supplements
FDA Import Alerts · Supplements
Last updated:

FDA Import Alert 54-10: Aristolochic Acid in Supplements

Import Alert 54-10 lets FDA detain herbal supplements and bulk botanicals without examining them when they are labeled as containing Aristolochia or related plants. Aristolochic acid causes kidney failure and cancer. Release needs LC-MS lab evidence that the product is free of it.

Short answer: FDA Import Alert 54-10 allows detention without physical examination of bulk or finished dietary supplements and drugs labeled as containing Aristolochia species or certain Asarum, Cocculus and Thottea species, because aristolochic acid is a potent carcinogen and kidney toxin. A product can be released when analytical evidence based on liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) shows it is free of aristolochic acid. Removal requests go to FDA's Division of Import Operations.

Listed on 54-10? Send us the product, botanical ingredients and shipment details. We plan the testing and the request.

Get a 54-10 Case Review
At a Glance

Import Alert 54-10 Basics

ItemImport Alert 54-10
Official titleDWPE of Bulk/Finished Dietary Supplement Products Containing Aristolochic Acid
BotanicalsAristolochia spp. and certain Asarum, Cocculus and Thottea spp.
Food charges402(f)(1)(A), 402(f)(1)(D), 402(a)(1)
Drug chargesUnapproved new drug 505(a); misbranded 502(f)(1)
ReleaseLC-MS evidence the product is free of aristolochic acid
Removal contactDivision of Import Operations, (301) 796-0356

Details follow the current text of Import Alert 54-10, published December 10, 2020.

Listed Products

Products Covered by 54-10

Aristolochia

Any Aristolochia species, as a supplement or ingredient.

Asarum (Xi Xin)

Listed Asarum species, including the one Red List entry.

Cocculus and Thottea

Listed species of both genera.

Chinese formulas

Traditional formulas known to contain aristolochic acid.

Bulk botanicals

Roots, powders and extracts.

Finished products

Capsules, tablets, teas and pills.

Known Formulas

Chinese Formulas FDA Lists as Containing Aristolochic Acid

  • Dang Gui Si Ni
  • Du Hou Ji Sheng Tang (Tuhuo and Loranthus Formula)
  • Xiao Qing Long Tang (Minor Blue Dragon Formula)
  • Chuan Xiong Cha Tiao Wan (Cnidium and Tea Formula)
  • Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang (Ephedra and Asarum Formula)
  • San Bi Tang and others named in the alert
Release and Removal

Two Tracks: Releasing a Shipment vs Leaving the List

Release one shipment

Analytical evidence that the product is free of aristolochic acid. FDA says only certificates of analysis or other documents that rely on liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) should be accepted to release detained product.

Removal from the Red List

The alert directs all requests for removal from DWPE to FDA's Division of Import Operations at (301) 796-0356. Expect FDA to want LC-MS results and proof of correct botanical identification.

Need samples pulled and tested for a detained supplement shipment? Our sister company, FDA Detention Sampling, coordinates sample collection, chain of custody and testing with LAAF-accredited laboratories nationwide. Call +1 (786) 561-3726.

Removal Evidence

What a Strong 54-10 Request Includes

  • The product, its botanical ingredients and the listing.
  • Botanical identity testing for each herb, with Latin names.
  • LC-MS results showing no aristolochic acid.
  • Supplier controls to prevent substitution or misidentification.
  • Labels with correct botanical names and no disease claims.
How It Works

Our Import Alert 54-10 Process

1
Review the productWe check each botanical against the species in the alert.
2
Identity reviewWe look for name confusion and substitution risks.
3
Testing planWe help plan LC-MS testing for aristolochic acid.
4
Evidence packageWe assemble identity, testing and supplier records.
5
Request and follow-upWe prepare the request to FDA and answer its questions.

FDA's framework is in RPM Chapter 9-8; FDA removal guidance explains what a request should include.

Related Help

Import Alert Resources

Import Alert Removal

Removal help for food and supplements.

Dietary Supplements

Supplement registration and labeling.

Import Alert 54-16

Supplements with hidden drugs.

Import Alert 54-07

Germanium supplements.

Import Alert 99-42

Heavy metals in herbal products.

Supplement Label Review

Check claims and ingredient labeling.

Start With the Listing

Get Help With Import Alert 54-10

We review the botanicals, plan LC-MS testing and prepare the request to FDA. We are an independent compliance firm, not FDA or a law firm, and no one can guarantee FDA's decision.

  • Custom-scoped quote based on your listing and products.
  • Exporters, manufacturers and U.S. importers.
  • Agree the scope and pricing before any paid work begins.

Contact our specialists, email info@fdaregistrationassistance.com, or call +1 (928) 275-8333. Import alert removal · Supplement services · Contact.

Get a 54-10 Case Review

FDA Registration Assistance is a private consulting firm, not FDA or any government agency. FDA registration is not FDA approval, clearance or certification.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions — Import Alert 54-10

What is FDA Import Alert 54-10?

Import Alert 54-10 is titled "Detention Without Physical Examination of Bulk/Finished Dietary Supplements Products Containing Aristolochic Acid." It lets FDA detain products labeled as containing certain botanicals without examining each shipment.

What is aristolochic acid?

A substance found in plants of the Aristolochiaceae family. FDA describes it as a potent carcinogen and nephrotoxin that causes kidney damage and can cause or contribute to kidney failure. Small amounts taken for years can cause serious, irreversible effects.

Which botanicals does Import Alert 54-10 cover?

Any Aristolochia species, plus listed species of Asarum, Cocculus and Thottea, as bulk or finished dietary supplements, drugs or other products, and products from firms named in the alert.

How does aristolochic acid end up in supplements?

FDA gives two ways: the plant on the label was misidentified, or it was confused with an aristolochia-containing plant because traditional Chinese names were misread or are similar.

Which Chinese herbal formulas are named in 54-10?

The alert lists formulas including Dang Gui Si Ni, Du Hou Ji Sheng Tang, Xiao Qing Long Tang, Chuan Xiong Cha Tiao Wan, Da Qin Jiao Tang, Ma Huang Fu Zi Xi Xin Tang, San Bi Tang, Jiu Wei Qiang Hou Tang and Qing Shang Juan Tong Tang.

What are the charges under Import Alert 54-10?

For supplements: adulteration under sections 402(f)(1)(A) (significant or unreasonable risk), 402(f)(1)(D) and 402(a)(1) (poisonous or deleterious substance). If the labeling makes disease claims, the product is charged as an unapproved new drug under section 505(a) and a misbranded drug under section 502(f)(1). Refusal is under section 801(a)(3).

Who is on the 54-10 Red List?

The alert currently shows one firm, Kaiser Pharmaceutical Co. in Taiwan, for Xi Xin (an Asarum product). Check Import Alert 54-10 for the current list.

How can a detained 54-10 shipment be released?

When the firm provides analytical evidence that the product is free of aristolochic acid. FDA says only certificates of analysis or other documents based on liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) should be accepted as a basis for release.

Why does FDA require LC-MS testing?

LC-MS can identify and measure aristolochic acid specifically. FDA does not accept results from less specific methods to release detained product under this alert.

How do I get removed from Import Alert 54-10?

The alert says all requests for removal from DWPE should be addressed to FDA's Division of Import Operations, at (301) 796-0356. Expect to show LC-MS results and correct botanical identification.

Do products with Asarum always fail?

Not necessarily. Products with listed botanicals should be evaluated to show they are free of aristolochic acid. Correct species identification and LC-MS results are what FDA looks at.

Who do I contact at FDA about Import Alert 54-10?

The alert lists the Division of Import Operations at (301) 796-0356 for removal requests, and the Office of Regulatory Science at (301) 796-6600 for sampling and analytical methods.

Does 54-10 apply to herbal teas?

The alert covers bulk and finished products of any type that contain the listed botanicals. The one Red List entry is classed as herbals and botanicals, not teas, but teas containing these plants can still be detained.

What does the U.S. importer need to do?

Importers must keep a Foreign Supplier Verification Program that covers aristolochic acid and botanical misidentification where it is a known or reasonably foreseeable hazard, with supplier verification and testing for higher-risk products. See our FSVP service.

Can you guarantee removal from Import Alert 54-10?

No. FDA makes every removal decision. We are an independent compliance firm, not FDA or a law firm. We help you build a complete, well-documented request.

HM
Reviewed By Hector Matos, Senior Regulatory Compliance Specialist · 15+ years FDA compliance experience · Updated October 2026
Discuss Your Project

Request an Import Alert 54-10 Case Review

Tell us what your company makes, sells, or distributes, where each product is manufactured or packed, your U.S. importer or buyer arrangement, label readiness, and target shipment date.

Submitting this inquiry does not purchase a service or authorize paid work. Our team can discuss the scope and required materials before you commission assistance. Fields marked with an asterisk are required.

Please do not include payment details, medical records, or other sensitive information. You can also email our team or call +1 (928) 275-8333.