Skip to main content

FDA Registration Assistance

FDA Import Alert 99-47 economically motivated adulteration of food
FDA Import Alerts · Food Fraud
Last updated:

FDA Import Alert 99-47: Foods Adulterated for Economic Gain

Import Alert 99-47 lets FDA detain foods and supplements from listed firms without examining them when they appear to be adulterated for economic gain. Honey with C4 sugar, lemon juice that is not all lemon, squid and shrimp sold with extra water or glaze and fake saffron are on it. Release needs third-party lab results that address the original finding.

Short answer: FDA Import Alert 99-47 allows detention without physical examination of foods and dietary supplements from listed firms that appear to be adulterated for economic gain, such as honey with added C4 sugars, lemon juice with added citric acid, seafood with excess glaze and saffron replaced by other plant material. The charges fall under section 402(b) of the FD&C Act. A detained shipment can be released with third-party lab results or revised labeling that address the violation. Removal requests go to Importalerts2@fda.hhs.gov.

Listed on 99-47? Send us the firm name, product and the finding behind the listing. We plan the testing and the removal request.

Get a 99-47 Case Review
At a Glance

Import Alert 99-47 Basics

ItemImport Alert 99-47
Official titleDWPE of Human Food Products That Appear to be Adulterated for Economic Gain
ProductsConventional foods and dietary supplements
ChargesSection 402(b)(1) to (4), refusal under 801(a)(3); codes OMITTED, SUBSTITUTE, CONCEALED, ADDED BULK
Red List53 firms in 23 countries; Vietnam, Turkey and Yemen have the most
Earlier alertsMany honey and juice firms moved from deactivated alerts 36-01 and 22-04
Removal contactImportalerts2@fda.hhs.gov

Details follow the current text of Import Alert 99-47, published October 13, 2026.

Listed Products

Foods Most Often Listed for Economic Adulteration

Honey

Multi-flower, acacia, lychee, thistle and comb honey with C4 sugar findings.

Lemon juice

Juice with substitution findings such as isocitric acid and carbon SIRA values.

Other juices

Pomegranate juice with anthocyanin and tartaric acid findings.

Squid and octopus

Frozen squid and octopus with added water or weight.

Shrimp and scad

Frozen shrimp with excessive ice glaze and scad with added substances.

Saffron

Saffron that tested as 0% saffron and 100% other plant material.

The Four Charges

How FDA Charges Economic Adulteration

SectionWhat it meansCode
402(b)(1)A valuable constituent was left out or removedOMITTED
402(b)(2)Another substance was substituted in whole or in partSUBSTITUTE
402(b)(3)Damage or inferiority was concealedCONCEALED
402(b)(4)Something was added to increase bulk or weight, or to make it look better or more valuableADDED BULK

FDA's examples include corn or cane syrup in honey, citric acid in "100% lemon juice", other oils sold as olive oil, cheaper fish sold as a more expensive species, unapproved colors in spices and water glaze counted in seafood net weight.

Release and Removal

Two Tracks: Releasing a Shipment vs Leaving the List

Release one shipment

Send the FDA Division compliance office in the notice all information supporting release, such as third-party lab analysis showing the violation has been overcome, or revised labeling. FDA reviews private lab packages; seafood short-weight packages rated acceptable can be released without further program review if there are no other violations.

Removal from the Red List

Information that adequately shows the producer has resolved the conditions behind the listing, such as supplier and raw material controls, authenticity testing and corrected net weight practices, so FDA has confidence future entries will comply. Email Importalerts2@fda.hhs.gov or mail the Division of Import Operations, under RPM Chapter 9-8.

Need samples pulled and tested for a detained food shipment? Our sister company, FDA Detention Sampling, coordinates sample collection, chain of custody and testing with LAAF-accredited laboratories nationwide. Call +1 (786) 561-3726.

Removal Evidence

What a Strong 99-47 Request Includes

  • The Red List entry and the analytical finding, such as C4 sugar or isocitric acid levels.
  • Root cause: where the substitution, dilution or added weight came from.
  • Supplier approval, traceability and raw material authenticity testing.
  • Corrected glazing and net weight controls for seafood.
  • Third-party lab results on later lots using methods suited to the finding.
How It Works

Our Import Alert 99-47 Process

1
Confirm the listingWe check the Red List entry and the analyte behind it.
2
Root causeWe trace the adulteration to supplier, blend or process.
3
ControlsWe help set authenticity testing and supplier controls.
4
Testing and evidenceWe plan sampling and assemble lab results and records.
5
Request and follow-upWe send the request to Importalerts2@fda.hhs.gov and answer FDA questions.

FDA's framework is in RPM Chapter 9-8; FDA removal guidance explains what a request should include.

Related Help

Import Alert Resources

Import Alert Removal

Removal help for food and supplements.

Import Alert 99-39

Misbranded imported foods.

Import Alert 45-02

Illegal or undeclared colors.

Honey Imports

FDA rules for honey products.

Seafood Import Rules

Species, net weight and HACCP rules.

Release a Held Shipment

FDA hold statuses and release steps.

Start With the Listing

Get Help With Import Alert 99-47

We find the source of the adulteration, set authenticity controls, coordinate testing and prepare the removal request. We are an independent compliance firm, not FDA or a law firm, and no one can guarantee FDA's decision.

  • Custom-scoped quote based on your listing and products.
  • Exporters, manufacturers and U.S. importers.
  • Agree the scope and pricing before any paid work begins.

Contact our specialists, email info@fdaregistrationassistance.com, or call +1 (928) 275-8333. Import alert removal · Food services · Contact.

Get a 99-47 Case Review

FDA Registration Assistance is a private consulting firm, not FDA or any government agency. FDA registration is not FDA approval, clearance or certification.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions — Import Alert 99-47

What is FDA Import Alert 99-47?

Import Alert 99-47 is titled "Detention Without Physical Examination of Human Food Products That Appear to be Adulterated for Economic Gain." It covers conventional foods and dietary supplements.

What is economically motivated adulteration?

FDA defines it as the substitution, addition or omission of a substance in a product to increase its apparent value or reduce its production cost for economic gain.

What examples does FDA give?

Corn or cane syrup added to honey, citric acid added to "100% lemon juice", hydrolyzed inulin syrup in apple juice, other oils sold as olive oil, cheaper seafood sold as a more expensive species, unapproved colors or fillers in spices and water glaze counted in seafood net weight.

What are the charges under Import Alert 99-47?

Section 402(b) adulteration, with refusal under 801(a)(3): a valuable constituent omitted (OMITTED), a substance substituted (SUBSTITUTE), damage or inferiority concealed (CONCEALED) or a substance added to increase bulk or weight or make it appear better (ADDED BULK).

Which foods are on Import Alert 99-47?

Mostly honey and lemon juice, plus pomegranate juice, frozen squid, octopus, shrimp, scad and saffron.

Which countries have firms on Import Alert 99-47?

The Red List has 53 firms in 23 countries. Vietnam has 7, Turkey 6, Yemen 5 and India 4.

What does a C4 sugar finding mean for honey?

Most honey listings cite C4 sugar levels, which point to added cane or corn syrup. The alert does not publish a numeric limit. See our honey registration help.

What did lemon juice tests find?

Lemon juice entries cite findings such as isocitric acid levels, carbon SIRA values, Brix, formol value and citric acid concentration, depending on the firm.

How do I know if my firm is on Import Alert 99-47?

Open Import Alert 99-47 and search the Red List by country and firm name. Each entry shows the product and the date it was added. Check before every shipment season, since the alert is updated often.

How do I get a 99-47 shipment released?

Send the FDA Division compliance office in the notice all relevant information, such as third-party lab analysis showing the violation has been overcome, or revised labeling. FDA lists methods under Import Alert Resources on its private laboratory testing page.

Is excess ice glaze on seafood a 99-47 issue?

Yes. Glaze counted as product weight is one of FDA's examples, and frozen shrimp from one firm is listed for excessive glaze added to increase apparent weight.

How do I get my firm removed from Import Alert 99-47?

Show FDA the producer has resolved the conditions behind the listing so future entries will comply. Email Importalerts2@fda.hhs.gov or mail the Division of Import Operations, 12420 Parklawn Drive, ELEM-3109, Rockville, MD 20857, following RPM Chapter 9-8.

Were these firms on other alerts before?

Yes. Many honey firms were previously on deactivated Import Alert 36-01, and several juice firms on deactivated Import Alert 22-04.

Who do I contact at FDA about Import Alert 99-47?

Removal petitions go to Importalerts2@fda.hhs.gov. The alert lists the Division of Import Operations at (301) 796-0356 or FDAImportsInquiry@fda.hhs.gov, and FDAPRIVATELABIMPORTALERTS@fda.hhs.gov for method questions.

Can you guarantee removal from Import Alert 99-47?

No. FDA makes every removal decision. We are an independent compliance firm, not FDA or a law firm. We help you build a complete, well-documented request.

HM
Reviewed By Hector Matos, Senior Regulatory Compliance Specialist · 15+ years FDA compliance experience · Updated October 2026
Discuss Your Project

Request an Import Alert 99-47 Case Review

Tell us what your company makes, sells, or distributes, where each product is manufactured or packed, your U.S. importer or buyer arrangement, label readiness, and target shipment date.

Submitting this inquiry does not purchase a service or authorize paid work. Our team can discuss the scope and required materials before you commission assistance. Fields marked with an asterisk are required.

Please do not include payment details, medical records, or other sensitive information. You can also email our team or call +1 (928) 275-8333.